Caulfield Family Stories
These early Caulfield stories are a kind of alternate universe for fans of The Catcher in the Rye — the time period is shifted by roughly five years with an older Holden killed in the war. The names of the Caulfield children are also changed somewhat: D. B. becomes Vincent and Allie becomes Kenneth. These Vincent stories also include the Gladwaller family which is absent from the later Holden stories.
As part of the story arc, Vincent is killed in World War II. This leaves his close friend, Babe Gladwaller, to tell Vincent’s girlfriend of his death.
- The Last and Best of the Peter Pans (1942, unpublished) Vincent argues with his mother about the draft for World War II
- Last Day of the Last Furlough (1944) Babe Gladwaller narrates his and Vincent’s last day at home before going off to war
- The Ocean Full of Bowling Balls (1945, unpublished) Vincent’s account of the death of Kenneth/Allie
- This Sandwich Has No Mayonnaise (1945) Vincent’s reaction to being notified of the death of his brother, Holden
- The Stranger (1945) Babe Gladwaller returns from the war to tell Vincent’s girl of his death
Salinger wrote about Holden, using him as his main character after 1945. He actually credits Buddy Glass with the writing of Catcher in the Rye, linking the Caulfield and Glass families in that one conceived of the other. The Holden stories all relate to the eventual plot of The Catcher in the Rye, which would become the last of the series.
- Are You Banging Your Head Against the Wall? (1941, unpublished) Reworked into Slight Rebellion Off Madison
- Holden On the Bus (1942, unpublished)
- I’m Crazy (1945) An alternate take the first chapters of Catcher
- Slight Rebellion Off Madison (1946) An alternate take on chapter 17 of Catcher
- The Boy in the People Shooting Hat (1948, unpublished) This story of “Bobby” and Stradlater later became chapters 3-7 of Catcher
- The Catcher in the Rye (1951) Holden’s account of leaving school
Caulfield Family Tree
These characters change over the span of several stories, making a strict family tree impossible. Vincent and D.B. appear to be the same character, as Allie and Kenneth appear to be the same character. We aren’t sure just who Curtis Caulfield is.
- Mr. Caulfield
- +Mary Moriarity
- Vincent/D.B. Caulfield (1914–1944) Died in Hürtgen Forest in WWII
- Holden Morrissey Caulfield (1933– or December 1923–1943) In This Sandwich Has No Mayonnaise, it says that he died “in the Pacific” in WWII, but The Catcher in the Rye places his age in 1949 as 16, making him way too young to have been in WWII. Raise High the Roof Beam, Carpenters makes this Curtis Caulfield instead, who may or may not be related.
- Allie/Kenneth Caulfield (1935–1946) Died as a child in 1946
- Phoebe Caulfield (1939–)
- Viola Caulfield
- +Mary Moriarity